Spare me more ‘savaging’ from Scotland’s ‘top educational expert’

I am sick fed up of reading Lindsay Paterson’s blinkered view of Scottish education in the Scottish media. It is nothing personal, I am sure he is a very nice chap. It is actually not his fault that, when I read a headline in the Herald that “Scotland’s top education expert savages education system”, I knew immediately who it was going to be.

Paterson is Professor Emeritus of Education Policy at Edinburgh University. He has a rose-tinted view of what education was like in Scotland in the late 20th century, a system in which he thrived.

Scotland’s journalists don’t challenge – even the normally acute Neil Mackay as in this recent Big Read – Paterson’s opinion that more suspensions and exclusions, more rote-learning and less child-centred education is the way to improve education in Scotland.

Paterson’s recipe might work for some kids – but not the huge cohort that are currently being failed. We have been hearing more from them recently than usual in the wake of the Alan Milburn report on NEETS, not in employment, education, or training. Some have been interviewed in the media this week and it has been moving to hear from young people without experience or qualifications, who are unable to get jobs however hard they try. It is heartbreaking – but it is not new.

One of Paterson’s dubious claims is that working-class children did better at school in the post-war era than they do now.

Eh what, Professor? Back then, only around 7% of Scots had the privilege of going to University. Most who did were not working class. Sure, if you did climb over the barriers and get a degree as Paterson did, you had a good chance of doing well in life, but for most working-class kids the odds of them doing that were heavily against.

There were far more NEETs back then than there are now too, though we called them NEDs, which stood for non-educated delinquent. It was about one in five, in the 1980s when I graduated, compared to one in six now. You could leave school at 16 in Scotland then, but in practice it was allowed after the fourth-year exams, so many kids left at 15.

Then it was straight onto the scrapheap for many. The 1980s were the days of Scotland’s rapid industrial collapse, accelerated by the Thatcher government’s wholesale hammering of the sector into the dirt. The period was memorialised in the Proclaimers song

“Letter from America”

Bathgate no more
Linwood no more
Methil no more
Irvine no more.

Heroin ran through many of those dispirited and destroyed communities like a virus. That gave us what we now call “the Trainspotting generation”. Of course it was not all bad – apart from the successful book and movie franchise Trainspotting, and The Proclaimers’ oeuvre, Scotland’s post-industrial wasteland also gave us the Dundonian games developers who made the global entertainment behemoth Grand Theft Auto.

But the black economy took hold in the kind of places where you find families today where nobody has worked for two generations. These are difficult problems to solve and tinkering with the curriculum is not going to do it.

The biggest predictor of being a NEET is the same as it was for a NED – persistent school absence. Paterson likes to point to PISA and argue that it proves England’s education system is working. But there are relatively small differences between the two countries – just a few per cent here and there (I looked at the last PISA here and here). All the UK countries have a huge issue with non-attendance and disengagement, particularly in secondary school.

Scotland’s rates of disengagement and non-attendance are significantly higher than the overall English average; a wee bit higher than the North of England and NI, and about the same as Wales. In part, that may be down to the fact that Scotland does not routinely fine parents for non-attendance by their children.

But the main reason has got to be that a lot of kids across all the UK countries don’t want to go to school. There was a committee meeting at the Scottish Parliament last week about persistent absence. The committee heard from Billy Anderson, head of services and influencing at Children in Scotland; Gavin Yates, executive director at Connect; and Lisa Weylandt, senior policy and public affairs officer at Includem.

It was refreshing to listen to them. How I wish Scotland’s media would give these educational experts, with first-hand experience of working with these children, the same kind of billing as Lindsay Paterson.

They agreed that a big percentage of Scotland’s children feel that school is not for them; it is not a place they enjoy going, they don’t feel welcome or included when they do show up

Weyland said: “We have heard a lot from children and young people saying that they feel really different, that things are too much for them and that their needs are more than the system can handle. When that messaging is internalised in children who are so young, it can set them up for a particularly tricky life or it can create additional challenges for them.”

Yates quoted a girl who said: “I am in the class, I am sitting with the class, the teacher is talking to the class, but I am not actually included in the class.”

Yates said: “When 50 per cent of pupils in our secondary schools have some kind of additional support need, is that mainstream education any more? Does mainstream education have to fundamentally change to encompass all neurodivergent children, or are we going to continue to fail them all?”

He said the public conversation had to change: “When was the last time you read an article discussing the pass rates at Nat 4 or vocational education or national progression awards? When did you ever read in an editorial in The Times, The Scotsman, The Herald or anywhere else about that? We simply do not see that. The public focus is about “the national qualifications”, as the press calls them. By that, it means Nat 5 and higher.”

Anderson said: “Previously I worked with an autistic lad who had been out of school for around a year and a half. We worked super hard on building his confidence and making him see the benefit in returning to school to try to do his exams. We managed to get to a point where we could get him over the threshold of the school, and I was the person who took him into school. He was highly stressed and anxious, so he lay across the chairs in the waiting room, just to self-regulate. The first teacher who approached berated him and said, “Do you think it’s appropriate to lie across there? Other people need to use those seats.” He sat up and got even more highly stressed, but a minute later, another teacher come along the corridor and said, “Hi, how are you doing? No seen you for a while. Come on, let’s hae a chat and talk about what you’ve done.” He never even gave me eye contact; he focused on the child and gave me a wee wink as he led him down the corridor. That contrast and the difference of culture within the school was stark.”

MSP for Cunninghame South in Ayrshire, Patricia Gibson, asked what school is for. The experts said, in a nutshell, schools should exist to serve kids, not the other way around. They added that the education system as we know it is largely a product of the factory age and it should be changed because it does not do that.

This reference to the factory age chimed with an essay I read in the NYT last week “What if there is no AI bubble?” Tech entrepreneur Azeeem Azhir argued that AI is competing for the white-collar wage bill, most companies’ biggest ticket item.

He said that AI will increase inequality in the way the Industrial Revolution did. Back then, mill owners made generational fortunes while cottage industries, which had given workers more control of their work and, in many cases, a better quality of life, were destroyed.

Is Azhir right? In fairness, I have to say that I have no idea. The other aspect of Neil Mackay’s piece on Paterson, with which I do agree, is his anger at news that background papers on curriculum improvement produced by Education Scotland include fake academic references that are presumably AI-generated hallucinations. (This was reported by Paterson’s colleague Brodie Runciman, a PE lecturer at Moray House, the education college, but I can’t find any published examples of the fakes). If AI was your intern, you would fire it for that.

On the other hand, I do not share Lindsay Paterson’s faith in the factory model of education, with its centralised “knowledge-based” curriculum designed to reward conformity. The yellow brick road is mined.

One of Scotland’s other top education experts, Billy Anderson, has a different view. He told the committee: “Success should not only be measured by exam results; it should be measured by how a young person feels. That is right at the heart of what a school is for. It is about how young people connect with other people; it is about developing skills for life and friendships for life.

“We should be asking children and young people what success means to them… We need to accept that society is changing. If we do not move with society and involve children and young people in what their vision for the future is, everybody will fail.”

He also said that the biggest thing that helps children to re-engage with school is relationships – it can be something as small as the same member of staff welcoming a child into school each day when they come back after a long absence. Isn’t that so simple, and so human?

Thanks for reading Scottish Notebook/ A Letter from Scotland! If you agree with my comments, please share this post. (You can share it if you disagree too, but I guess that’s less likely.)

Share